Cozy Flannel Collar,Choices

So here's what I made yesterday.

With the flannel at least:

a wider version of my peter pan collars.

 It's so cozy soft, when I tried it on, I didn't want to take it off!

 I sewed velvet ties on, then thought, since both sides are the same, maybe I should just do a hook and eye closure and a covered button...

This covered button's print is the same as the coffee cozy I made recently ;)

 here are some other options:

 with the ties, it almost reminds me of little red riding hood's hood ;)

 I picked up a bunch of art deco looking jewelry parts at a craft store a while back, with intentions to make brooches. I think they are awaiting the perfect project.Is this it?

Which way do you prefer? Ties, brooch, covered button?

As much as I like this collar, the more I look at it, the more it seems to be calling out for an attached capelet. Can you see it?

I think I'll get more flannel! This flannel is from Moda, and it's so soft and nice. Love the subtle plaid colors in a current favorite shades of midnight blue.